Posted by Grassapelli on Thursday, September 9, 2010
With my latest post to the Fiddle and violin blog I am shifting a long held belief about fiddle and violin. Just where this is going, I don't know.
To illustrate my point, if I have one, and that is not certain...
I have embedded a YouTube video of two teen age string students. A violinist and a cellist put together a performance of Super Mario themes.
It is done extremely well. The music shows their classical training and study. But, the spirit is not serious or classical.
Another side of the same question is raised by The Dueling Fiddlers. Two virtuoso violinists are using fiddle techniques and classical training to create rock performances. Again, just extremely well done.
My first reaction was, "Well, that's great, but it isn't fiddling." Now, as I'm seeing more crossover performances, I'm reevaluating my opinion.
Thursday, September 9, 2010 @10:38:12 AM
I think your first reaction was right!
So-called 'serious' players aren't exempt from 'having fun' (and I think there can be no doubt that they are)! The end result, however (as I've viewed in your video) is a little too 'stiff' rhythmically (as well as too 'bold' harmonically) to be (IMO) 'bona-fide' fiddlin'...
Can they play CHICKEN REEL with a straight face?
Wednesday, September 15, 2010 @10:02:04 AM
I agree with your observation. Now I'm thinking that there is a third kind of playing that is neither fiddling nor classical. It's pop. And the most accurate term would be pop violin.
Not aware of what pop fiddling would be.
You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.
'Gold Tone Banjola' 10 hrs
'Help buy new Fiddle' 14 hrs
'New Fiddlin Stool' 2 days