DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online fiddle teacher.
Monthly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, fiddle news and more.
Pretty much every violin tutorial teaches a straight left wrist as a proper hand position-- but I've had the opportunity to watch some great fiddle players up close who play with a partially pancaked wrist. Not completely pancaked to the point of the heel contacting the fiddle, but definitely pushed in and agile. So I've been trying this and find it seems to benefit my intonation, gives better tone with less pressure, and cleans up my rolls. To make this work my thumb is really high so the 'mouse hole' is pretty small. I read somewhere that 'intrinsic' hand (not arm) muscles are activated when the wrist is bent in this way but I have no idea if that is really what is going on.
What is your experience?
I’ll try anything that cleans up my rolls, haha.
I”ll give it a try and report back!
( if anybody has the secret to a good second-finger roll, lemme know…I’m working on a reel where I play 2nd finger roll (mushy), 2nd finger roll (mushy), then 1st finger roll (perfect) and it sounds weird because it’s so clear that I can’t do 2nd finger ones! I guess I’ll try to practice them on their own and figure out what’s going on …)
Keeping the wrist straight is key to developing good left hand technique. If you only play in first position, you can get away with a lot of bad posture because you aren’t shifting or making significant stretches (like fingered octaves or tenths). This is why a lot of fiddlers have bent wrists—the tunes they play don’t have the technical requirements of other violin literature.
The fact that one can get away with bad posture is not an argument in its favor, however. A bent wrist actually strains the hand more. It’s common to hear fiddlers describe difficulty reaching the fourth finger, even in first position, a problem that is easily avoided with good posture. The benefit of a good left hand position is that it places the fingers directly over the strings so that they can simply drop down. This is much more effective in improving intonation, cleanness, and speed. And the position of the wrist doesn't just help with the fingers and hand, it helps with the tendons in the whole lower arm and even helps with the upper arm and shoulder to some degree.
A change in position can sometimes appear to yield results without truly doing so. The conscious effort to change posture can lead to increased attention to detail, which can give the false flag of an overall improvement. It’s vital to progress to make long-term changes by adopting good technique. Incorporating bad habits only slows you down and makes you play more out of tune.
If you want to study posture, pay attention to players who play the most technically challenging literature, not the players who play repertoire that can be played even with poor posture.
Stage show performers can play the violin behind their backs, over their heads, or under their legs. That doesn’t mean that what they’re doing is good for tone production or technique, even if you find it exciting to watch.
A few fiddlers have found ways to play DESPITE bad technique, not BECAUSE of it. A mistake that a lot of other players make is in assuming that they’ll get similar results by copying the eccentricities of players they admire. It doesn’t work that way. Playing is hard enough on the body when done properly. Why compound it with bad technique?
Edited by - The Violin Beautiful on 11/19/2026 07:21:32
@Rich I found the article that inspired me to try this. Have a read and look at the wrist photo halfway down. That's the position I'm taking about.
https://www.violinist.com/blog/callen46/20268/30839/
I don't think this is bad technique. It's a hand position that works for some (including me!)
@NCnotes, relaxing both thumbs is my key for good rolls, and the hand position seems to help there too. That and raring back the roll-executing finger so it really drops at the very last moment to do the cut.
I find that playing 1st position on A and E strings, the pancake is not terrible, but for notes on D and G I try to straighten out the wrist and more importantly swing the elbow out a bit to not have to stretch the fingers so much. The pancake lets me rest the hand a bit during those 3-4 hour gigs. But straight is def a better position if you can keep at it.![]()
Edited by - wrench13 on 11/19/2026 10:51:37
quote:
Originally posted by JonD@Rich I found the article that inspired me to try this. Have a read and look at the wrist photo halfway down. That's the position I'm taking about.
https://www.violinist.com/blog/callen46/20268/30839/
I don't think this is bad technique. It's a hand position that works for some (including me!)
@NCnotes, relaxing both thumbs is my key for good rolls, and the hand position seems to help there too. That and raring back the roll-executing finger so it really drops at the very last moment to do the cut.
The photo of the different hand positions suggests an alternative position where the back of the hand isn't aligned as in the standard. Oddly, though, the picture of the player holding an instrument depicts the standard position, not the "enlightened" one. Do as I say, not as I do?
I have to disagree with the article. The standard violin technique has produced the greatest violinists in history. If it were true (I don't believe it for a second) that the standard position was physically worse, I'd still consider it a worthwhile sacrifice to achieve good results. Being comfortable is not as important to me as playing well. But I have to question the validity of the argument that standard technique is so detrimental to the body. Yes, I acknowledge that other violin is not the most ergonomic instrument to play, but in the last few decades, new-age shamans like this one have tried all kinds of things to adapt playing position and make it more comfortable. Yet with all these attempts to redesign the wheel, the incidence of playing injuries has not decreased. Players spend much more time complaining of injuries and discomfort now than they ever did before. Either the old players were a lot tougher than the current players or the newer methods don't actually produce the claimed results.
When I was first learning the violin, I was taught to keep the back of the hand straight. To reinforce this, a teacher drew a face on the inside of my hand. If I could see that face while holding the violin, I was in trouble. It was often taught that one should be able to place a straightedge against the forearm and have it reach straight to the back of the hand. This posture keeps the fingers up above the fingerboard and right over the strings. The neck is held between the base of the index finger and the thumb, leaving a gap at the crotch of the thumb. My father used to check this when I was little by putting a finger in the gap while I was playing. If there wasn't enough room for a finger, it was a problem. It would be simple to just drop the neck into that gap, but that would put the fingers at a bad position relative to the fingerboard. Ease of playing outweighs comfort.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.