Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Nov 14, 2026 - 6:18:14 PM
like this
589 posts since 6/3/2016

I haven't been communicative here lately. For the last five months or so I've been playing with a mostly acoustic not-a-band. Here are some videos from a recent Porchfest performance. There was a problem with the audio, so this is just cell phone audio. This is my first attempt at playing contemporary material. I need another five months!

Black Water

Speed of the Sound of Loneliness

This is one of my favorites. There is an intonation problem at the very beginning. sorry!

Someday Soon

Honky Tonk Moon

This one is a challenge for me. It's a Blues-in-E song written by the lead guitar player. I don't play in E Major at all, so improvising in E is a challenge. This is probably only the fourth time I played it with the group, so I am pretty happy.

Bad Tattoo Blues

We played a similar gig a week later with better audio, but so far there's no video. There are two songs from that I would like to post if/when available.

Ernie

Nov 14, 2026 - 8:00:26 PM
likes this

4231 posts since 10/22/2007

I get it. One band I played in, always kicked off the show with Folsom Prison Blues, in E. Baptism by fire indeed! Like everything, It gets better with more tries.
The band sounds nice. You've got your part within the music figured out. No two fiddlers would fit or sound the same. That's the cool part. Thanks for sharing!

Nov 15, 2026 - 6:44:48 AM
like this

2219 posts since 7/30/2021

Really like that “Someday Soon” song too! You guys sound good!!

yea, improv in e-minor? Phew! For songs where I got stuck, I used to record, take home and play along with the recording.

Nov 15, 2026 - 7:46:58 AM
likes this

martyjoe

Ireland

412 posts since 7/11/2024

E major is a handy key to play in if you do it regularly. Alto sax is an Eb instrument so anything in G becomes E on the Alto. The funny thing is because I'm so used to it on the sax I don’t struggle with it on the fiddle.

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:56:23 AM
likes this

960 posts since 11/26/2013

Looking for honest appraisal, Earnie?

Nov 16, 2026 - 6:59:09 PM

589 posts since 6/3/2016

quote:
Originally posted by NCnotes

Really like that “Someday Soon” song too! You guys sound good!!

yea, improv in e-minor? Phew! For songs where I got stuck, I used to record, take home and play along with the recording.


As you suggest, recording and playing along with recordings is a big part of what I am doing. And of course I am also listing to other recordings.

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:15:43 PM

589 posts since 6/3/2016

quote:
Originally posted by wrench13

Looking for honest appraisal, Earnie?


Sure, go for it!

When I posted the video I was tempted to give my laundry list of problems, but I refrained myself. Here are some systematic technique problems that jump out to me.

  • My tone is not good, still too much of a scratchy fiddler
  • It depends on the song, but I have timing issues and tend to rush
  • It depends on the song, but when I have intonation issues I tend to be flat

I haven't worried about much more detail than that, as I think that's enough to work on. Regarding style, maybe my accompaniment is too busy, but  so far no-one's complaining. I've gotten the stink eye for much less in my experiments with bluegrass years ago.

I've been taking classical violin technique lessons since the beginning of the year. At the beginning of the year, a big focus was on tone production and getting a better sound. I've made improvements, but still have a long ways to go. I think my teacher gave up on that battle, but recently said she wants me to work on tone/volume again. So I'm starting to work on scales exercises in the Scales Plus! book by William Starr. I think I remember that you do a lot of scale work!

I rush for different reasons. Sometimes it's because I think we're playing a song too slow and subconsciously I just want to play faster. Sometimes I think it's because I'm improvising, and I'm so happy that I know what I want to play I feel I have to play it as soon as possible.

Sometimes my intonation issues are because I can't hear myself, but for those recordings I had an amplifier nearby. I also have in-ear monitors (not that day). Some of the intonation issues are systematic.

I've only been playing with this group since early June. Even for the songs we're playing now I need another half year.

Edit: One detail. On an instrumental/solo in Black Water, I had to press a boost pedal switch and it messed up my timing! That kind of thing I can live with.

Edited by - RinconMtnErnie on 11/16/2026 19:21:24

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:03:55 PM
likes this

4231 posts since 10/22/2007

All that stuff is your critical mind. Folks love a fiddle. H@ll, I can't figure it out? But I love playing in a band because it is forgiving. I still have a pickup, but usually play into a mike. That way I can turn around and learn the song before I play the break.
Okay, I'm always in some sort of double-stop. Also I shuffle. I dunno, about 75% of the time. Thing is, that's me. You're not obligated to play any way other than what you want. That's Art. There is no wrong. ( if you're on pitch) If you've got an ideal and you're missing the mark a bit that's alright. That's you! You do you!

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:45:11 PM

960 posts since 11/26/2013

OK here goes.
Way too many guitars. Overall too busy. The lady with the uke - extraneous. Keys adding nothing. Drummer, so dead/stiff you may as well have a drum machine. The lady lead singer is the talent, nice voice and control. Honestly sounds like 7 people who just happen to be playing the same song rather then a cohesive band, with everyone listening and complimenting the overall sound, but that is just more rehearsal time - you're right about the six months (maybe more). You need more volume and some decent EQ to tweak out the scratchy-ness and beef up the woody tones. What is your rig and set up? Play the rests, the spaces in the vocals, but as it stands the music has no room to breath, every one is banging away in one way or another. Despite the drum, sounds like not every one is dead on with the timing too, contributing to the mushy sound. I didn't find your intonation all that bad, but its hard to hear the fiddle in the mix. Me, I'd ditch the keys and uke, get the bass to play a electric, find a better drummer and put 6-10 months of serious rehearsal and orchestrating whose playing what and where. Good bands don't just happen, especially with mid level players. That takes work.

Nov 17, 2026 - 7:10:56 PM

589 posts since 6/3/2016

Al,

To give some context, in my original post I called this a "not-a-band". Because it's not really a band. It's a friendly group of musicians who like to get together, play music, and have a beer or two. Earlier groups of some of these people had a tighter sound. We certainly want to sound better! The drummer is a back-up drummer whose primary instrument is guitar. Our original drummer had a life changing event where he couldn't play the gig. I'll reply separately about myself so as to focus on fiddle.

Nov 17, 2026 - 7:41:05 PM

589 posts since 6/3/2016

Regarding my setup, I was originally playing with a Fishman V-200 pickup. But because of odd circumstances I would have to take the pickup on and off every week. So I'm currently using a Headyway The Band2 pickup, which wraps around the lower bout underneath the bridge and can quickly attached or detached.

I am using a Fishman Aura Spectrum DI preamp with violin images, of course. I am using an MXR Micro Amp as a volume boost pedal.

We always practice with a PA system. While it's not crazy loud, it's loud enough that I can't hear myself well unless I have an in-ear monitor (IEM) and/or an amplifier used as a monitor. When playing with an in-ear monitor, I have a transmitter plugged into the balanced XLR out of the Fishman Aura preamp. The output of the boost pedal goes straight to the mixer. The nice thing about just two pedals is I can run battery operated without a pedal board and fit all my electronics and cables in a small backpack.

If I don't use an IEM, as on that day, then the boost pedal goes to an amplifier, and an output of the amplifier goes to the mixer. I had to use a borrowed amp that day as the amp I planned to use had developed a hiss that couldn't be repaired without sending it back to the manufacturer (per a local amplifier repair technician).

The fundamental problem with the mix is there's no sound guy to fix problems when we're playing. A friend of the group in the audience called out "more fiddle" after the first song or two. And then after another song or two he called out "more fiddle" again.

I haven't really given much thought to EQ. At minimum the Fishman Aura has a basic 3-band EQ, so I should experiment with that.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.0859375