DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online fiddle teacher.
Monthly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, fiddle news and more.
It's been a few years since I posted here, but I'm still fiddling and still grateful to everyone who offered their advice in the past.
(Quick post summary at end)
So one of my favorite things to do when I have the time is to tune my fiddle to an old recording and play along. I always learn something.
I recently played along with the Skillet Lickers' Hell Broke Loose in Georgia and I had to tune just slightly sharp of a half step sharp (so roughly Ab, Eb, Bb, F). I've had to tune sharp before, but never this much.
I was surprised by how much my fiddle came to life. The overall playability and tone was simply great. Tunes with a kind of trill (e.g. Bucking Mule) became even easier to play.
So, I'm wondering if this was all because of the different frequency, which resonated better with my fiddle's body, or was it the increased tension that made the fiddle resonate better. It's already a good fiddle, but the difference was very noticeable. It was like it became less shrill, but more brilliant at the same time.
If the answer is increased tension, then maybe I can get a similar effect by switching to heavier gauge strings. I'm currently using a mix of old medium helicores and superflexibles. If it's all just a result of tuning up and getting a better resonance because of the actual notes of the open strings, then there's not much I can do if I'm playing with friends.
What would you all recommend to try getting a similar level of tension? I'm not sure if I want to try helicore heavies (there are no superflexibles in heavy gauge), or maybe even Prims, potentially just mediums as they are already heavier than helicores. I'll probably look for something else for the E string, because I don't like a plain steel/unwound E string.
Another consideration is whether to just get heavy gauge for the A and E strings since I frequently tune up to cross/high bass.
Short summary:
I recently read how the stiffness/flexibility of violins respond to different tensions. The author says basically that stiffer violins respond better to higher tension strings whilst more flexible violins respond better to lower tension.
I had a situation where the piper in our session broke his chanter reed so he had to play his low pipes which are tuned down 2 semitones. We all had to tune down to match and my fiddle came to life (not my playing). Everyone could hear the difference.
What is happening in your case could be as described or some other factor. There are so many variables.
Without seeing the violin in person, it’s hard to diagnose it. I’d say that, in general, higher tension leads to a more focused band of sound under the ear, which may give the impression of more power and a more brilliant tone. Because players today gravitate toward a brighter, crisper sound, high tension is in vogue.
But string tension is not the only factor. The body of the violin may indeed seem to respond to a certain frequency, although if it’s not speaking well at standard pitch, that’s a red flag. It may also be a false flag for what’s really a setup issue. Neck projection, neck length, body length, stop length, and vibrating string length all play important parts.
Setup is such a crucial part of violin sound, and I don’t think that’s sufficiently understood on this forum. Soundpost position and tension can completely transform an instrument. For example, the principal cellist of an orchestra brought her cello in for an adjustment a week ago because the A string was just so piercing and the instrument was rather unbalanced. A quick look at the soundpost revealed that it was quite far out of position and it was frighteningly tight. The only way I could move it was to loosen the D and A strings. Because the player needed it back right away for a concert later and I didn’t have time to cut a post on the spot, I just moved the post to a more optimal position. The cellist was pleased with the improvement but agreed to bring the cello back later for a shorter soundpost. This week she returned and brought along the soundpost that had previously been in the cello. I put that one in and found that it was a much better fit and tension, so we went with that one. The player was instantly amazed by the transformation and exclaimed “I’ve got my cello back now!”
The cut of the bridge plays an important role as well. The bridge acts as a filter for the impulse coming from the vibrating strings so that the top will vibrate in a way that promotes wanted frequencies. This is why just fitting the feet and setting the height alone don’t make for a good bridge. A bad bridge will choke a fiddle.
String choice has a significant impact as well. Depending on the set, you can emphasize different sound characters.
To a lesser degree, things like tailpiece choice, tailgut, afterlength, nut height, saddle height, and the chinrest all affect sound.
When you’re looking at a violin, you’re seeing a complex system of proportions and relationships that coalesce to produce the sound. While a single thing may be at issue, it’s rarely that simple or straightforward.
That's reall interesting makes perfect sense.
Overall, I am already very much in love with the sound and playability of this instrument, so I was quite surprised at the improvement. It was the third and long-unused violin of an orchestra violinist. I got it cheap because it "needed repairs" (it actually just needed strings).
I know this can't substitute seeing it in person, but I could describe something about it.
It's very thin and lightweight overall, weighing only 400 grams without a chinrest. The body, neck and sides (ribs?) are all thinner than my other fiddles, even the top plate is quite thin judging by its thickness at the f holes.
The bridge is a custom bridge that is also so thin that some people have commented that it could start to bend someday, but it's been serving me well for 10 years. I don't trust myself to adjust the soundpost, but in the past I experimented with moving the bridge to adjust the sound, but I put it back where it was.
It can be really loud and has a full, balanced sound, but can be a bit shrill and unforgiving. Getting a good pernambuco bow was a big help for that.
I worry whether it is too fragile for heavy gauge strings, but frequent cross tuning has never been an issue.
It's only ever been to a luthier to fix a snapped endpin.
I've tuned it up to two whole steps lower and everything in between, but none of those tunings were ever an improvement. It's fairly bright in tone, but has pretty great sound on the G and D strings too.
Its action is very low, but I like it.
quote:
Originally posted by The Violin BeautifulWithout seeing the violin in person, it’s hard to diagnose it. I’d say that, in general, higher tension leads to a more focused band of sound under the ear, which may give the impression of more power and a more brilliant tone. Because players today gravitate toward a brighter, crisper sound, high tension is in vogue.
But string tension is not the only factor. The body of the violin may indeed seem to respond to a certain frequency, although if it’s not speaking well at standard pitch, that’s a red flag. It may also be a false flag for what’s really a setup issue. Neck projection, neck length, body length, stop length, and vibrating string length all play important parts.
Setup is such a crucial part of violin sound, and I don’t think that’s sufficiently understood on this forum. Soundpost position and tension can completely transform an instrument. For example, the principal cellist of an orchestra brought her cello in for an adjustment a week ago because the A string was just so piercing and the instrument was rather unbalanced. A quick look at the soundpost revealed that it was quite far out of position and it was frighteningly tight. The only way I could move it was to loosen the D and A strings. Because the player needed it back right away for a concert later and I didn’t have time to cut a post on the spot, I just moved the post to a more optimal position. The cellist was pleased with the improvement but agreed to bring the cello back later for a shorter soundpost. This week she returned and brought along the soundpost that had previously been in the cello. I put that one in and found that it was a much better fit and tension, so we went with that one. The player was instantly amazed by the transformation and exclaimed “I’ve got my cello back now!”
The cut of the bridge plays an important role as well. The bridge acts as a filter for the impulse coming from the vibrating strings so that the top will vibrate in a way that promotes wanted frequencies. This is why just fitting the feet and setting the height alone don’t make for a good bridge. A bad bridge will choke a fiddle.
String choice has a significant impact as well. Depending on the set, you can emphasize different sound characters.
To a lesser degree, things like tailpiece choice, tailgut, afterlength, nut height, saddle height, and the chinrest all affect sound.
When you’re looking at a violin, you’re seeing a complex system of proportions and relationships that coalesce to produce the sound. While a single thing may be at issue, it’s rarely that simple or straightforward.
Edited by - Jimbeaux on 11/14/2026 10:42:19
A half step is a bigger change to the instrument than most people expect, since string tension goes as the square of the pitch - raising everything a half step adds roughly 12% more pull, so the top is working differently as well as ringing at a different frequency. Worth knowing too that a lot of prewar 78s sit well above today's A=440, because pitch standards and recording speeds varied a good deal before standard pitch settled in, so the fiddle may simply be meeting the recording where it lives. Given a thin, light instrument I'd go gently: a common approach is to change only the A and E to a heavier gauge and give it a good week of playing before judging, because a flexible top can be choked by heavy strings rather than brightened by them. On the E, many players who don't like a bright plain steel E sort it out by trying two or three different E strings rather than a whole new set, since that's where the shrillness usually lives.
verve
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.