Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


What key would these be in if the fiddle was tuned to standard pitch?

Nov 11, 2026 - 1:54:45 PM
1594 posts since 7/26/2015

What key would these be in if the fiddle was tuned to standard pitch? I've always been uncertain which of these tunes were played in C fingerings with them being tuned sharp vs. played with D fingerings and tuned flat. Does that make sense? Sometimes I think one fiddler might be playing with C fingerings and the other with D fingerings and they each retuned so their fingerings would end up in the same key. What do you think?

I'm Going Away in the Morn
youtube.com/watch?v=Om8VjQIu7hk
Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel
youtube.com/watch?v=utxhke3wnbo
Go Long Mule
youtube.com/watch?v=Uv1h870Y4Qg
Rabbit in the Pea Patch
youtube.com/watch?v=-XfDZ1LgwVs
Sleepy Lou
youtube.com/watch?v=3S6gwinkktA

Grey Cat On the Tennessee Farm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nX8WfmB_t3k

Edited by - soppinthegravy on 11/15/2026 17:31:18

Nov 15, 2026 - 8:38:30 AM
like this

1 posts since 2/10/2026

I'm Going Away in the Morn - D
Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel - D
Go Long Mule - D
Rabbit in the Pea Patch - D
Sleepy Lou - C

Nov 15, 2026 - 5:32:39 PM

1594 posts since 7/26/2015

I forgot to put this one in the original post:

Grey Cat On the Tennessee Farm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nX8WfmB_t3k

 

quote:
Originally posted by fireball2006

I'm Going Away in the Morn - D
Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel - D
Go Long Mule - D
Rabbit in the Pea Patch - D
Sleepy Lou - C


Nov 18, 2026 - 9:09:42 AM

4231 posts since 10/22/2007

quote:
Originally posted by soppinthegravy
I forgot to put this one in the original post:

Grey Cat On the Tennessee Farm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nX8WfmB_t3k

 

quote:
Originally posted by fireball2006

I'm Going Away in the Morn - D
Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel - D
Go Long Mule - D
Rabbit in the Pea Patch - D
Sleepy Lou - C


 


Grey cat-

It's a bit sharp but still in D.

Nov 18, 2026 - 10:12:39 AM

verve

USA

13 posts since 11/16/2026

Nice question. A helpful way to think about it is to separate fingerings from the sounding key. If you play the familiar D-shape fingerings with the open D and A strings ringing, and you retune the fiddle a whole step sharp, those D-shape fingerings tuned a whole step sharp sound in E. If someone else uses C-shape fingerings and retunes flat to land in the same sounding key, their fingerings are just shifted; you both end up sounding in the same key while calling them by different names.

A practical way to pin the sounding key: listen for the drone or open-string notes. If the two open strings that ring form a perfect fifth on D and A, the piece sounds in D. If they ring on C and G, it sounds in C. The retuning just decides which fingerings get you there. Most of these are built around a D-A drone, which is why the community tends to call them D tunes even when a fiddler's instrument was pushed a little sharp.

verve

Nov 19, 2026 - 6:37:58 PM

1594 posts since 7/26/2015

That's what I'm talking about. But, for some reason, with these particular recordings, it's harder to tell by the drones, at least to my ear which makes me wonder if one fiddler is using different shapes than the other.
quote:
Originally posted by verve

Nice question. A helpful way to think about it is to separate fingerings from the sounding key. If you play the familiar D-shape fingerings with the open D and A strings ringing, and you retune the fiddle a whole step sharp, those D-shape fingerings tuned a whole step sharp sound in E. If someone else uses C-shape fingerings and retunes flat to land in the same sounding key, their fingerings are just shifted; you both end up sounding in the same key while calling them by different names.

A practical way to pin the sounding key: listen for the drone or open-string notes. If the two open strings that ring form a perfect fifth on D and A, the piece sounds in D. If they ring on C and G, it sounds in C. The retuning just decides which fingerings get you there. Most of these are built around a D-A drone, which is why the community tends to call them D tunes even when a fiddler's instrument was pushed a little sharp.

verve


Nov 19, 2026 - 6:40:27 PM

1594 posts since 7/26/2015

On this one and Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel, I wonder if  one of the fiddlers is using what would be ADAD tuning if they were tuned to standard pitch.
quote:
Originally posted by farmerjones
quote:
Originally posted by soppinthegravy
I forgot to put this one in the original post:

Grey Cat On the Tennessee Farm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nX8WfmB_t3k

 

quote:
Originally posted by fireball2006

I'm Going Away in the Morn - D
Jordan's a Hard Road to Travel - D
Go Long Mule - D
Rabbit in the Pea Patch - D
Sleepy Lou - C


 


Grey cat-

It's a bit sharp but still in D.


Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.0859375