Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Nov 9, 2026 - 6:45:50 PM
7144 posts since 8/7/2009

...who has experience with them and what is your impression? ...relative to other sets: Helicore mediums, Prims mediums, and Jargar mediums, or whatever else you may have used.

I quit using the Helicore mediums because the winding on the A string does not last (my experience).

Nov 10, 2026 - 6:05:52 AM
like this

RobBob

USA

3048 posts since 6/26/2007

I use Helicore heavy G and Titanium A in a set with a Prim medium D and a Lisa medium E on my fiddles and get a loud, clean sound with a set that holds up well. Great tone and longevity. I will and have subbed a Jargar D and other E's on occasion to good end. Helicore mediums are too thin imho.

Nov 11, 2026 - 7:20:13 AM

7144 posts since 8/7/2009

quote:
Originally posted by RobBob

I use Helicore heavy G and Titanium A in a set with a Prim medium D and a Lisa medium E on my fiddles and get a loud, clean sound with a set that holds up well. Great tone and longevity. I will and have subbed a Jargar D and other E's on occasion to good end. Helicore mediums are too thin imho.


Thanks for the comment, Bob.  I'd love to hear the story behind how you settled on those choices..

I've had a few people tell me that the heavy gauge strings have better presence and projection and a darker tone. Sounds like less work with better tone. But  I'm wondering if the difference is that dramatic.  My the bigger concern is the durability. I've always been disappointed with the Helicore A strings on the medium set. They wear out too fast. Does the heavy gauge A last longer, or does it suffer from the same wear issues?

I may give them a try...
 

Nov 11, 2026 - 11:26:34 AM
likes this

2682 posts since 3/1/2020

Heavy gauge strings require more tension to reach the target pitch. Higher tension sets often sound louder under the ear, and I think that’s why the trend toward high tension in all string sets has taken off in the last couple decades. I think plain loudness gets conflated with presence or depth a lot. If it’s louder right under the ear, there’s an incorrect assumption that it’s better and more powerful at a distance. A lot of strings sound very shrill and cutting from that vantage point but rather pathetic at a distance. Loudness gives edge, but volume gives richness.

Steel strings are commonly thinner than other varieties because steel allows for a thinner core. Some players find them too thin, and at high tension, the thinner strings are more uncomfortable on the fingertips.

I don’t think the heavy gauge Helicores are really all that different tonally. You’d really get a lot more for your money by choosing a different brand.

I’ve been saying for years that D’Addario has pretty significant quality control issues. Even the packaging doesn’t work as intended anymore.

Nov 11, 2026 - 12:10:04 PM

DougD

USA

13120 posts since 12/2/2007

Tony, the aluminum winding on the Helicore A string is a common complaint. Have you ever tried the titanium wound A?
You could try the heavy set, but my luthier used to say that lost the "slinky" feel of the mediums, which is what many people like. They make a titanium wound A in heavy gauge too.
I tried Helicores once and thought they were OK, but Prim suit me better.

Nov 11, 2026 - 3:08:33 PM

7144 posts since 8/7/2009

I like the Prims. I switched to them after playing the Helicores for a number of years, 4 fiddles with Prims and 1 with Jagars.

I like the Jagars. They are said to be "darker" - but I'm not really sure about that. They do sound nice, easy to play, and they last. My ear can't really tell much difference between them and Prims. I'd play them except - I have to order them (Prims are local). Not a real big deal, I'd have to order the Helicore heavy too.

Strange... I've also be told (by some) that Prims are brighter that Helicores. Not to my ears. Helicores seem to be the brightest to my ears.

Nov 11, 2026 - 3:20:51 PM
likes this

7144 posts since 8/7/2009

quote:
Originally posted by The Violin Beautiful

Heavy gauge strings require more tension to reach the target pitch. Higher tension sets often sound louder under the ear, and I think that’s why the trend toward high tension in all string sets has taken off in the last couple decades. I think plain loudness gets conflated with presence or depth a lot. If it’s louder right under the ear, there’s an incorrect assumption that it’s better and more powerful at a distance. A lot of strings sound very shrill and cutting from that vantage point but rather pathetic at a distance. Loudness gives edge, but volume gives richness.

Steel strings are commonly thinner than other varieties because steel allows for a thinner core. Some players find them too thin, and at high tension, the thinner strings are more uncomfortable on the fingertips.

I don’t think the heavy gauge Helicores are really all that different tonally. You’d really get a lot more for your money by choosing a different brand.

I’ve been saying for years that D’Addario has pretty significant quality control issues. Even the packaging doesn’t work as intended anymore.


Yes. I am aware of the tension issue.  For my playing - it isn't an issue.  But I am concerned about the added tension for the fiddles - with cross-tuning. I'll probalby need to watch the bridge a little closer. 

Yes.  I did say presence, projection, and darker tone - not loudness.  I'm not really going for "loud". One fiddle is very responsive, but weak in the lows, and takes a while to "wake up" (no presence under the ear). I feel like I'm having to work to hard - to get what I want out of it.  But then - as you say - it's really hard to tell what it is sounding like "out there". I really love the responsiveness - but I wish i could relax more when I'm playing it - and have confidence that I'm filling that "space".

I've had someone suggest a sound post adjustment, but - we really don't have anyone in our area (Memphis) that I think would really know what they are doing.  I know that what Bob and Doug have said about the A string is true. I can't figure out why the A string is wound with Aluminum.  WHY?

And your suggestion for a different brand - for tonal improvement over Prims?

Nov 11, 2026 - 6:36:23 PM

2682 posts since 3/1/2020

A strings are commonly wound with aluminum. I think the reasons for this are that it’s been determined that aluminum works well tonally and that it allows the diameter of the string to be thicker than it would be if it was wrapped with silver. Silver D strings are considerably thinner than aluminum D strings. I suspect a silver A would be thin enough that it would bother players. I can’t say whether it would be a tonal improvement because I’ve never seen a silver A. I wish one were available just to try.

There are other A strings that aren’t aluminum wound. Warchal makes a Russian style out of stainless steel. It’s very thin, not much thicker than a heavy E. Russian school players sometimes choose a synthetic or gut G and D and a steel A and E, a setup that was popular in the old days. It feels radically different and changes the sound of the violin to more clearly delineate the upper strings from the lower. Warchal also came out with a special A for their Timbre set that has a helical twist at the bow area. It’s also stainless steel. Larsen brought out an alternative A string for their Il Cannone set, but that was really more of a way to use marketing to try to distract from the complaints that the A strings had longevity issues. After Rondos became a hit among players, a new A string was developed as an option, made of carbon steel. Like the other A strings, it’s quite thin. Although there are several options available, the aluminum wound A is by far the most popular. But it's also the string that breaks most easily in just about every set. Some string varieties are infamous for unraveling. 

One of the biggest logistical problems of switching to a thinner string is that its diameter will not be accounted for at the nut or bridge. That means you have to redo the string grooves to make things appropriate or play an unbalanced setup. Thinner strings cut into bridges more easily as well, so then it’s also worth it to put a parchment under the A.

As far as steel sets, I think Prims are about as good as it gets. If you want more depth, you can accomplish that with a good synthetic set. If you choose a bad synthetic set, it’ll sound more like steel, just with better projection.

You really can’t go wrong with Dominants. They give a perfect balance of everything. If you want extra power but want to keep as much color as possible, Rondos are a great choice. If you want a set that’s built to fill halls and focus on power, PI is a great choice. If you like Dominants but want a set that’s cheaper and sounds nearly as good, Tonicas are a solid choice.

Edited by - The Violin Beautiful on 11/11/2026 18:41:18

Nov 12, 2026 - 5:20:06 AM
likes this

RobBob

USA

3048 posts since 6/26/2007

quote:
Originally posted by tonyelder
quote:
Originally posted by RobBob

I use Helicore heavy G and Titanium A in a set with a Prim medium D and a Lisa medium E on my fiddles and get a loud, clean sound with a set that holds up well. Great tone and longevity. I will and have subbed a Jargar D and other E's on occasion to good end. Helicore mediums are too thin imho.


Thanks for the comment, Bob.  I'd love to hear the story behind how you settled on those choices..

I've had a few people tell me that the heavy gauge strings have better presence and projection and a darker tone. Sounds like less work with better tone. But  I'm wondering if the difference is that dramatic.  My the bigger concern is the durability. I've always been disappointed with the Helicore A strings on the medium set. They wear out too fast. Does the heavy gauge A last longer, or does it suffer from the same wear issues?

I may give them a try...
 


Durability is one reason I came up with this combo.  Also less string noise on fast string crossings. We get 9 months to a year out this combination. That's with regular playing. I don't fiddle as much as I used to but my wife fiddles more than ever and she likes this set.

Nov 12, 2026 - 6:18:42 AM

7144 posts since 8/7/2009

quote:
Originally posted by The Violin Beautifu

There are other A strings that........


Thanks Rich.

Nov 12, 2026 - 6:22:30 AM

7144 posts since 8/7/2009

quote:
Originally posted by RobBob
quote:
Originally posted by tonyelder
quote:
Originally posted by RobBob

I use Helicore heavy G and Titanium A in a set with a Prim medium D and a Lisa medium E on my fiddles and get a loud, clean sound with a set that holds up well. Great tone and longevity. I will and have subbed a Jargar D and other E's on occasion to good end. Helicore mediums are too thin imho.


Thanks for the comment, Bob.  I'd love to hear the story behind how you settled on those choices..

I've had a few people tell me that the heavy gauge strings have better presence and projection and a darker tone. Sounds like less work with better tone. But  I'm wondering if the difference is that dramatic.  My the bigger concern is the durability. I've always been disappointed with the Helicore A strings on the medium set. They wear out too fast. Does the heavy gauge A last longer, or does it suffer from the same wear issues?

I may give them a try...
 


Durability is one reason I came up with this combo.  Also less string noise on fast string crossings. We get 9 months to a year out this combination. That's with regular playing. I don't fiddle as much as I used to but my wife fiddles more than ever and she likes this set.


I may buy the Prim heavy gauge G and D and try them with the Prim A and E - just to see.... 

Thanks!

Edited by - tonyelder on 11/12/2026 06:38:33

Nov 14, 2026 - 6:43:03 PM

589 posts since 6/3/2016

I use heavy-tension Helicores on my best fiddle. I would never have chosen them on my own. But it came new with them, and I liked them! That fiddle has a very low action. So it does not require any extra effort with the left hand. Everything sounds good on that instrument with those strings.

I have not put them on other instruments.

Nov 16, 2026 - 4:52:40 AM

2682 posts since 3/1/2020

Some players use heavy gauge/high tension strings as a way to try to squeeze more power out of an instrument that has an anemic sound. It’s often a bandaid fix that doesn’t address the root of the problem, which could be low projection, a bad neck angle, overstand issues, or a mediocre setup. Adding more tension in that scenario often chokes the sound more, and while it may make it more focused in certain areas and more piercing, it strips away the rest of the tone palette.

Nov 17, 2026 - 6:10:29 AM

RobBob

USA

3048 posts since 6/26/2007

If you compare a set of meduim Helicores to a medium set of Pirastro Flexocore, I think you will find that the Helicores are thinner. Hence the use of the heavy Helicore. Also, your specific instrument and the sound you are searching for is important in this application

Nov 17, 2026 - 8:14:41 AM

verve

USA

13 posts since 11/16/2026

Heavy gauge only reaches pitch at higher tension, so it's worth comparing the actual numbers before switching sets.

For anyone playing octave mandolin, bouzouki, mandocello or five-string fiddle, there are some free printable chord charts and a string tension guide here, no sign-up needed to read them: lowstrings.discourse.group. Happy to answer questions about the low ones right here too. - verve

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.4296875