DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online fiddle teacher.
Monthly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, fiddle news and more.
I'm working on playing the low strings over chords in various keys. The V chord in E is B. I found B D# F#, the B on the G string to the D# on the D string, 3 high to 1 low a stretch. I tried playing like I'd play a C, with 3,1,3 fingers. It was easy to just shift my hand down a half step. But then it messed me up for the next chord. I gave up on it but then read about something called 1/2 position where all fingers move down a half step. So I'm thinking maybe there's something two it and now I should practice shift 1/2 step down and then back. Good idea?
Learning to play in half position is useful. To do so doesn’t require a true shift of the hand, more a move of the fingers back a little. It’s intended as a quick departure and you should be able to switch back and forth with first position seamlessly. Just practice it intentionally and it’ll get easier. I’m pretty sure there are etudes devoted to this.
quote:
Originally posted by buckhenryMy hand has to shift right back to the peg box for half position, that's when I realised the importance of how the pegs are staggered as they are, the peg would be in the way other wise.
Sometimes when I change strings I find I have to rewind the E string so the peg doesn't interfere. Especially playing an F. (I should do that today - I changed strings a couple weeks ago and that peg is annoying).
quote:
Originally posted by Brian Woodquote:
Originally posted by buckhenryMy hand has to shift right back to the peg box for half position, that's when I realised the importance of how the pegs are staggered as they are, the peg would be in the way other wise.
Sometimes when I change strings I find I have to rewind the E string so the peg doesn't interfere. Especially playing an F. (I should do that today - I changed strings a couple weeks ago and that peg is annoying).
I did it, and my guess of moving the string about 1/4" in the peg hole was perfect. My knuckle won't keep banging into it now.
Probably the way I hold my hand. It has always been a problem. Or maybe you have small knuckles. It may be ideal to have all the pegs set at the best position for tuning, but do you have a method to achieve that other than trial and error like I do on the E string? I don't really care much about the position of the other pegs because once they're set I tune from the fine tuners and seldom from the pegs. I've heard caution against doing that but I have never had a problem of pegs freezing up, if that's what people worry about. And there is no wear and tear on the pegs or holes. An advantage in my opinion.
I gotta agree with Rich here and say it’s probably easier to not think of it as a shift to another position, but more like reaching back a bit with your first finger on the D (like you’re playing an E-flat)? KEeping your hand in the normal ‘usual’ position will make it feel more natural & easy to play the following notes after the chord, without taking the time to shift your hand again.
A lot of this may depend on overall hand position. If you have a “pancake” hold, the hand will already be pointing somewhat backward, making the fingers strain more. Having to stretch further back for half position is therefore more of a strain. But if you have a straight wrist and the fingers are coming down straight onto the strings, not at an angle, it won’t strain the hand to reach to half position, it’s more a matter of compressing the fingers close to the nut. A shift is a move of the whole hand frame, but half position doesn’t require this. The thumb may stay anchored in the usual spot and only the fingers need move.
No, I don't have a method to achieve that other than trial and error, and I don't bother about the peg positions either, I was just stating a fact that those who do tune with the pegs position them like so, because that's how I found out the reason why I was having difficulty with it when I tried to it along time ago. And I'm doubtful I have small knuckles standing at 188cm.
I disagree that the 1/2 position is just a backward extension. In the latter the hand, including the thumb, stays anchored in first position and only the 1st finger reaches back for the 'low' 1st finger notes. The other fingers stay in 1st position.
For the 1/2 position the entire left hand shifts back towards the scroll by a half-step, including the thumb. All the fingers move back, including the third finger ( low 3 ) which no longer can be tuned an octave above the lower open string, well maybe tuned to the major 7th interval. This is when one may notice that the hand shifts as far back past the nut and rests on the peg box.
There is no reason for the whole hand to shift for a move of a half step. Galamian taught students to play in half position without moving the hand, just moving the fingers back a little.
Looking at historical treatises, shifting the hand for different positions, especially adjacent ones, was far less common before the modern method of playing. But even with more careful attention to each position, there were still certain cases where the fingers were expected to move outside the standard hand frame position. Some literature just demands the hand to stretch (Paganini in particular) without making a shift.
A lot of the complication in playing half position is getting over the mental concept of the fingers being squished together. But this doesn’t really make a lot of sense when you compare it to playing in higher positions along the fingerboard, where interval spacing is smaller.
I can think of several reasons for the whole hand to shift back to half position:
1) In one of my Gypsy pieces a part of the friss section in E minor the notes on the D string are: ED#EF# GF#ED#, I play those note fingerings: 2123 4321 (which is half position), this is convenient due to the notes that precede and succeed. This same fingering is then transposed up a semi-tone to F minor repeating the exact fingering as in the previous key, very convenient.
2) If I were to write a composition in E Minor with a Spanish flavour, I want to include a section of the piece to repeatedly alternate between V and the bVI chords, and I like the sound of a particular major chord that is fingered: G3, D1, A2, which moves back and forth from half-position to first-position as required: B-C chords. Included is a short melodic line on the V (B) chord thus requiring to remain in 'half' position for some notes in the B Phrygian Dominant scale: B C D# E.
3) Traditional pedagogues, like Wohlfahrt and Whistler, among others have written etudes not just for quick alterations but entire, multi-page etudes entirely in keys like F minor or B major. They explicitly teach the student to shift the entire hand frame back to 'half' position.
One time, at a gig, my singing/guitarist partner mistakenly put his capo on the 4th fret for A minor, but this is actually Ab minor. To avoid interrupting the proceedings I began to play in Ab Minor where the fingering is exactly the same as A Minor, but in the 'half' position. If one is experienced with shifting positions in A Minor this can easily be accomplished in Ab Minor.
Edited by - buckhenry on 10/08/2026 17:10:49
quote:
Originally posted by buckhenryNo, I don't have a method to achieve that other than trial and error, and I don't bother about the peg positions either, I was just stating a fact that those who do tune with the pegs position them like so, because that's how I found out the reason why I was having difficulty with it when I tried to it along time ago. And I'm doubtful I have small knuckles standing at 188cm.
I disagree that the 1/2 position is just a backward extension. In the latter the hand, including the thumb, stays anchored in first position and only the 1st finger reaches back for the 'low' 1st finger notes. The other fingers stay in 1st position.
For the 1/2 position the entire left hand shifts back towards the scroll by a half-step, including the thumb. All the fingers move back, including the third finger ( low 3 ) which no longer can be tuned an octave above the lower open string, well maybe tuned to the major 7th interval. This is when one may notice that the hand shifts as far back past the nut and rests on the peg box.
I think of "position" and "shifts" in OP as more about fingering and step layout positions. Not so much physical position knuckle or thumb touches the neck (which might vary for individuals)
OP described, the B and F# notes played with third finger, rather than the second. For key of B major for example (finger # and step pattern).
Fourth string fingering: 1=G#, 2=A#, 3=B, 4=C# (whole/half/whole)
Third string fingering: 1=D#, 2=E, 3=F#, 4=G# (half/whole/whole)
Second string fingering: 1=A#, 2=B, 3=C#, 4=D# (half/whole/whole)
Essentially the same as first position C major, just everything shifted down a half step. It is useful, and perhaps more comfortable than using second finger on respective B/F# and the fourth finger for D#/A#.
A lot folks focused simply on the first finger, to me that's just low first finger, the key of F or Bb... still just first position, still regular second and third fingers layout/pattern. While in sharp keys, like B, it is possible to keep B/F# as second finger and then temporarily reach back for D#, it can be a stretch (sep and half) for some folks; and requires same finger to play adjacent notes, a little clunky at speed (i.e. if need include the E note)
Another useful option to learn is to shift up, so the B is the first finger, making fingering layout.
Fourth string fingering: 1=B, 2=C#, 3=D#, 4=E (whole/whole/half)
Third string fingering: 1=F#, 2=G#, 3=A#, 4=B (whole/whole/half)
Second string fingering: 1=C#, 2=D#, 3=E, 4=F# (whole/half/whole)
I think this is the most used pattern layout, often referred to as finger capo method; intuitive transferable; easier and common doublestops and arpeggios.
Learning this latter, as well as initial half-step down; also just gives you more options to voicing and flow... from just linear melody, to arpeggios and double stops.
-------
As far as shifting hand, some of these are generally slight, and feels natural to do this and helps range of motion feel comfortable. But the hand/knuckle hitting peg... there should be plenty of space from nut to peg. IMO represents the hand is really too far back, to be most effective; probably even in first position. I mostly notice this when folks struggle to use pinky.
Edited by - alaskafiddler on 10/08/2026 18:43:40
Forgot to add... I notice a lot of folks use first finger as guide/reference to hand placement? I generally use my third finger (comfort/strength) as more the anchor guide first; then let that help determine where overall hand connects to neck position.
In first position, knuckle is generally around the nut, with approximately an inch gap to the peg.
quote:
Originally posted by alaskafiddlerBut the hand/knuckle hitting peg... there should be plenty of space from nut to peg.
I'm not sure why you are quoting me, because I did not say that, another member said it.
quote:
Originally posted by buckhenryThis is when one may notice that the hand shifts as far back past the nut and rests on the peg box.
My knuckles go past the nut, which i would call the 'peg box' region.
One's knuckle will be at least opposite the nut, depending on hand size. either way the hand shifts back from first position.
And I'm not sure why you are pointing out the various keys that are played starting the first finger, eg Ab and B Major.
I practice three octave major scales beginning on these notes G-Ab-A-Bb-B-C, consecutively, and I think I'm reaching Db but the notes become a little tight up the top.
Edited by - buckhenry on 10/10/2026 18:40:48
I wouldn't bother messing around in 1/2 position for fiddle tunes in E Maj
i would just gravitate toward the Pentatonic scale for the key of E Maj. E, F#, G#, B, C#.
Just use B & F# notes for the first inversion (B D# F#)
And F# & B notes for 2nd Inversion (F# B D#).
Fit the D#(3rd) in when you need it.
Edited by - pete_fiddle on 10/11/2026 12:54:10
quote:
Originally posted by buckhenryI can think of several reasons for the whole hand to shift back to half position:
1) In one of my Gypsy pieces a part of the friss section in E minor the notes on the D string are: ED#EF# GF#ED#, I play those note fingerings: 2123 4321 (which is half position), this is convenient due to the notes that precede and succeed. This same fingering is then transposed up a semi-tone to F minor repeating the exact fingering as in the previous key, very convenient.
2) If I were to write a composition in E Minor with a Spanish flavour, I want to include a section of the piece to repeatedly alternate between V and the bVI chords, and I like the sound of a particular major chord that is fingered: G3, D1, A2, which moves back and forth from half-position to first-position as required: B-C chords. Included is a short melodic line on the V (B) chord thus requiring to remain in 'half' position for some notes in the B Phrygian Dominant scale: B C D# E.
3) Traditional pedagogues, like Wohlfahrt and Whistler, among others have written etudes not just for quick alterations but entire, multi-page etudes entirely in keys like F minor or B major. They explicitly teach the student to shift the entire hand frame back to 'half' position.
One time, at a gig, my singing/guitarist partner mistakenly put his capo on the 4th fret for A minor, but this is actually Ab minor. To avoid interrupting the proceedings I began to play in Ab Minor where the fingering is exactly the same as A Minor, but in the 'half' position. If one is experienced with shifting positions in A Minor this can easily be accomplished in Ab Minor.
The examples you provided are likely places where the use of half position could be an option, but they are not proof that the hand needs to shift to play them. In fact, the point about shifting back and forth between first and half positions really reinforces the idea that shifting is unnecessary. Again, it's a step back of a half step. It should put no real strain on the hand. Especially if you happen to have large hands, shifting will be a less complicated matter. Paganini was said to have been able to reach as far as tenth position without shifting (this is sometimes speculatively attributed to the effects of Marfan Syndrome).
I agree with the point that if the hand is resting so far back on the neck even in first, it's probably back too far even there and will likely be the cause of other problems (e.g. intonation issues, difficulty in using the fourth finger, difficulty in reaching beyond first position for finger extensions). The thumb and base knuckle of the index finger form a basis for the rest of the hand frame. If the thumb is out of line, it puts undue stress on the hand and arm, especially if it's slanted backwards.
quote:
Originally posted by The Violin Beautifulquote:
Originally posted by buckhenryI can think of several reasons for the whole hand to shift back to half position:
1) In one of my Gypsy pieces a part of the friss section in E minor the notes on the D string are: ED#EF# GF#ED#, I play those note fingerings: 2123 4321 (which is half position), this is convenient due to the notes that precede and succeed. This same fingering is then transposed up a semi-tone to F minor repeating the exact fingering as in the previous key, very convenient.
2) If I were to write a composition in E Minor with a Spanish flavour, I want to include a section of the piece to repeatedly alternate between V and the bVI chords, and I like the sound of a particular major chord that is fingered: G3, D1, A2, which moves back and forth from half-position to first-position as required: B-C chords. Included is a short melodic line on the V (B) chord thus requiring to remain in 'half' position for some notes in the B Phrygian Dominant scale: B C D# E.
3) Traditional pedagogues, like Wohlfahrt and Whistler, among others have written etudes not just for quick alterations but entire, multi-page etudes entirely in keys like F minor or B major. They explicitly teach the student to shift the entire hand frame back to 'half' position.
One time, at a gig, my singing/guitarist partner mistakenly put his capo on the 4th fret for A minor, but this is actually Ab minor. To avoid interrupting the proceedings I began to play in Ab Minor where the fingering is exactly the same as A Minor, but in the 'half' position. If one is experienced with shifting positions in A Minor this can easily be accomplished in Ab Minor.The examples you provided are likely places where the use of half position could be an option, but they are not proof that the hand needs to shift to play them. In fact, the point about shifting back and forth between first and half positions really reinforces the idea that shifting is unnecessary.
Well, they are the options I chose, because I'm required to play a short passage in each scenario. So it is proof enough for me that the position shift is required to retain my hand frame. I think this position change is much easier than altering the hand frame for an all-finger backward extension, especially if one has much experience shifting.
Again, it's a step back of a half step. It should put no real strain on the hand. Especially if you happen to have large hands, shifting will be a less complicated matter.
For a backwards half step finger extension, I agree, no real strain on the hand, but I'm required to remain in half position for a short phrase. Are you suggesting I maintain an-all-finger backward extension for an entire song in Ab Minor? This would require my thumb to be in a continuous forward slant, putting much strain on the hand. That's like saying it's not necessary to shift position to play one octave Bb major scale commencing first finger. It's only matter of a few millimeters of movement, whats complicated about that.
Paganini was said to have been able to reach as far as tenth position without shifting (this is sometimes speculatively attributed to the effects of Marfan Syndrome).
Just because Paganini could do this doesn't mean I should even attempt it.
I agree with the point that if the hand is resting so far back on the neck even in first, it's probably back too far even there and will likely be the cause of other problems (e.g. intonation issues, difficulty in using the fourth finger, difficulty in reaching beyond first position for finger extensions).
I don't know where that point was made, but those problems will occur if all the fingers are in backward extension rather than in half position.
The thumb and base knuckle of the index finger form a basis for the rest of the hand frame. If the thumb is out of line, it puts undue stress on the hand and arm, especially if it's slanted backwards.
This is precisely the reason for the position shift to half position, not just a momentary-one-note backward extension, but a whole position change, where all the fingers are required to play a half step lower. In this case if the thumb does not move it will slant forwards destroying the basis for the rest of the hand frame, thus causing undue stress.
Edited by - buckhenry on 10/11/2026 21:30:21
There are all sorts of examples where the hand frame remains intact while the fingers move out of it. Half position is just the easiest example. But if you play fingered octaves, tenths, or even a Paganini caprice that stretches to a 14th, the hand has to accommodate a finger position. The place that the thumb is anchored is still vitally important, especially as you move around the neck in shifting or onto the fingerboard in high positions. For half position, the thumb has no real reason to move backward and crowd the pegbox and nut. The rest of the neck has more room for the hand to stretch out, but the nut is a fixed point and bunching the hand against the pegbox is just bad form. It also doesn’t allow a proper range of finger motion for vibrato. Bending the fingers back sounds theoretically like a strain, but the fingers should be able to accommodate a half step movement. The thumb and base joint of the index finger don’t need to move, just the upper joints of the fingers. So in answer to the question, I would say that there is no issue in playing a whole piece in half position without shifting the hand. But that’s not a very realistic scenario anyway. Half position is not used for long periods typically, and it’s far more preferable to make a momentary finger extension and then return to first position. You’ll see tons of examples of this in violin literature. The extent of the playing in that position is often just a few notes.
As the thumb starts to rest on the fingerboard or top instead of the neck, the hand stretches more as the positions get higher. At the end of the board, the thumb will be extended quite far unless it slides down the edge of the board, risking pitch instability. You might say that this contradicts the concept of the hand frame, but it makes sense when you consider a few things:
1) the upper bout of the violin is a barrier to shifting for the hand that requires workarounds
2) the interval spacing is much narrower at the upper end of the board
3) the thumb remains anchored to the instrument to help in maintaining pitch accuracy through muscle memory. Even though it is no longer a frame position in which the thumb and index knuckle are parallel, the body of the violin dictates a different frame that remains largely the same as the player moves into high positions.
Some players try to develop a sense of the hand just floating up and down the neck. This is promoted by the use of shoulder rests to remove the hand from the equation of holding the instrument up. The theory is that this allows the hand freer movement and makes it so that the hand frame can be more identical along the board (the thumb is no longer a failsafe against dropping the instrument). However, watching great players shows a very different picture of hand posture.
Amateur players are often misled by the idea that the key to improvement is to be more dogmatic—perhaps even more so than the professionals. The key that really unlocks things is to learn which dogmas are worth adopting and which are just wasted effort for little to no reward.
Your instinct is good — getting comfortable a half-step back toward the nut is worth practicing for playing the V chord in E, and it will pay off in B, F, and Bb any time they come up. The cleanest way to do it is to think of it as compressing the finger spacing rather than relocating the whole hand: keep the thumb and the base of the index knuckle roughly where they sit in first position and let only the fingers reach back, so you can glide straight back into first position for the next chord instead of having to re-set. Practice the B D# F# double-stop (and the 3,1,3 fingering you found) a half-step back, then immediately return to a first-position chord in E — that in-and-out motion is what makes the shift seamless. If you are mostly playing tunes in E at jams, you can also sidestep the stretch: play just the B and F# and drop the D# in when you need it, or add the open A to the B/F# double-stop for a handy B7 triple-stop that sounds great in the key of E.
-- verve
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.