Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Fiddle Lovers Online

 All Forums
 Other Fiddle-Related Topics
 Sound Off! (for Fiddle Audio File Posts)
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: Old-Time TOTW #185: Rose in the Mountain (1/9/22)

Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link:

FiddlerPaul71 - Posted - 01/09/2022:  06:37:26

Old-Time TOTW #185 is Rose in the Mountain from the playing of John Morgan Salyer (20 January 1882--18 November 1952) from Magoffin Co., KY. He was the son of Morgan Mason Salyer (1842-1913) and Katherine Patrick (1864-1885). He married Minnie Gullett (1884-1972) on 11 August 1905. John Salyer's ancestor, Benjamin K. Salyer (b. 1670 in France), supposedly a Huguenot with the name "DeSalier" or "Desalier," was listed as a "land owner" in Charleston, SC, 1690-1700. (source: Jana Buck Hanks and George Stokes)

John Salyer was heavily influenced by his close neighbor, and later musical partner, Willie Fletcher (b. 1871). He learned many of his tunes from Fletcher and said him to be "the sweetest and smoothest fiddler I ever heard." His son Grover recalled "He [John Salyer] played for a lot of dances...I've seen him...playing for a hoedown dance and he'd jump up and dance and play the fiddle at the same time." Another fiddler friend of John's was William Hamilton Stepp (1875-1957). Several tunes that Stepp and Salyer played in common are remarkably similar, and it's very possible that they learned some tunes from each other. Salyer's son Glen said of Stepp, "I liked to hear him play. He was considered a good fiddler, and he was. He loved to entertain people...more than Dad did." There were fiddle contests now and then in the Magoffin area, but Salyer rarely participated in them.

Along with his two sons, Grover (1910-1994) and Glen (1914-2003), on guitar and mandolin, respectively, Salyer was invited by the Sandy Valley Grocery Company to be entertainers at the 1933 World's Fair at Chicago. The train started picking up passengers in Pikeville, KY and continued to Cincinnati, OH. They provided music on the train. The playing continued until they arrived in Cincinnati. There they were joined by the Gibson Girl singers, and from there to Chicago, they alternated singing and playing. When they arrived in Chicago at 10:30pm, they were greeted by a bagpipe band. They stayed at the Stevenson Hotel. The second night the Salyers were invited to play for a dance in the million dollar ballroom of the Knickerbocker Hotel. The dance floor was make of glass blocks with many colored lights in it. There were 6,500 people in attendance, and they wanted a variety of dance music. John and his sons played the music they knew and encouraged people to dance however they wanted to it

Salyer never recorded on any record labels, as he felt they did not share enough of the profits with the fiddlers. Glen and Grover convinced him to record many of his tunes at home in 1941-42. He was reluctant, but his sons convinced him to do it. At one point, in frustration over not recalling part of a tune, he threw his fiddle down on the bed and refused to record any more, but Glen and Grover convinced him to continue

I wish to thank Bruce Greene not only for the above information, but for doing so much to collect and preserve so much history and the tunes themselves. Bruce Greene's website is

About the tune, Traditional Tune Archive states:

Jeff Titon (2001) is of the opinion the tune might have once been a march, although source John Salyer played it as a reel/breakdown. Titon believes the first strain of “Rose on the Mountain" published by Knauff in 1839 (No. 3) is related, but I find the tune strain similar only in a few measures at the end, and not cognate. There is no musical relationship with Kentucky fiddler J.P. Fraley’s similarly titled “Wild Rose of the Mountain."

I played through Knauff's Rose on the Mountain, and I can see how Salyer's Rose in the Mountain might have grown out of that tune.

Joining me are friends Stephen Rapp on banjo (Kent, OH), and Jean and Jeff Getz from Pittsburgh, PA, on bass and guitar, respectively.

Old-Time TOTW is able to continue through your support. If you'd like to be a part of this journey, join my Patreon at:

I offer some excellent perks for my Patrons.

Subscribe to my YouTube channel, and be sure to click the bell icon to receive notifications, and don't forget to join the Old-Time TOTW group on Facebook at:

bsed55 - Posted - 01/09/2022:  14:21:44

Nice! I've loved this tune ever since I learned it a couple decades or so ago. The best memory associated with this tune is when Bob Bovee & Gail Heil came to my home town to do a library program. That evening we were playing a session at the hotel where they were staying. Chirps came and joined us. Gail led off this tune to my total delight.

groundhogpeggy - Posted - 01/09/2022:  19:06:29

Nice playing, guys. Nice tune. It reminds me of Tucker's Barn. Has some similarities to my ear anyway. Thanks for another good ol' tune.

wilford - Posted - 01/09/2022:  19:27:12

That's a catchy tune. Nice group of musicians. Thanks for posting.

FiddlerPaul71 - Posted - 01/10/2022:  17:18:02

Thanks, Y'all, and yes Peggy, there is something about it that is similar to TB. Haven't played that one in a long time. Now that you've got me thinking about it, I should see if it'll come out again

Edited by - FiddlerPaul71 on 01/10/2022 17:18:35

groundhogpeggy - Posted - 01/10/2022:  18:10:07

Lol...ok I'll be waiting to hear that

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent
Copyright 2024 Fiddle Hangout. All Rights Reserved.

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories