Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

243
Fiddle Lovers Online


Discussion Forum

Hide these ads: join the Players Union!

 All Forums
 Other Fiddle-Related Topics
 Notation/Tab/Recording/Chords/Lyrics Requests
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: Fiddle TAB - TablEdit


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.fiddlehangout.com/archive/55211

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/09/2021:  01:53:11


Hi Guy's So I'd like to try my hand at writing some basic fiddle TAB TEF files in TablEdit. And I am struggling to figure out how to enter a 1L 2H symbols on the string. Help

RB-1 - Posted - 05/09/2021:  14:21:42


Archie, I wouldn't bother using these symbols,



I'd choose writing it as a mandolin tab for that is chromatic, so always shows you exactly where to put your fingers, independent of the key you're playing in.



Which comes handy as I'm trying Bluegrass and Newgrass that are using key changes and chord sequences outside a single mode.



But that's me, I can sight read and play fiddle from mandolin tabs, but this H - L stuff confuses me no end.



Standard notation with it's sharps and flats is equally confusing in a similar way.



But tab, to me, is just for figuring out where the fingers are supposed to be, after that, the tune itself I can remember...


Edited by - RB-1 on 05/09/2021 14:22:08

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/10/2021:  16:04:51


quote:

Originally posted by RB-1

Archie, I wouldn't bother using these symbols,



I'd choose writing it as a mandolin tab for that is chromatic, so always shows you exactly where to put your fingers, independent of the key you're playing in.



Which comes handy as I'm trying Bluegrass and Newgrass that are using key changes and chord sequences outside a single mode.



But that's me, I can sight read and play fiddle from mandolin tabs, but this H - L stuff confuses me no end.



Standard notation with it's sharps and flats is equally confusing in a similar way.



But tab, to me, is just for figuring out where the fingers are supposed to be, after that, the tune itself I can remember...






Thanks Bruno. I don't play fiddle or mandolin, but I do like to dabble with fiddle tabs I've found. My goal in learning basic fiddle tabs is to tab out basic melodies that I can practice backup banjo. As far as I understand H & L represent high and low notes possibly an octive apart ? I am just not sure.

soppinthegravy - Posted - 05/10/2021:  19:26:28


Make tab for "Mandolin GDAE", then, rename the instrument "Fiddle GDAE" when you are done writing the tune, and TablEdit will convert it to fiddle tab.       


quote:

Originally posted by Tam_Zeb

quote:

Originally posted by RB-1

Archie, I wouldn't bother using these symbols,



I'd choose writing it as a mandolin tab for that is chromatic, so always shows you exactly where to put your fingers, independent of the key you're playing in.



Which comes handy as I'm trying Bluegrass and Newgrass that are using key changes and chord sequences outside a single mode.



But that's me, I can sight read and play fiddle from mandolin tabs, but this H - L stuff confuses me no end.



Standard notation with it's sharps and flats is equally confusing in a similar way.



But tab, to me, is just for figuring out where the fingers are supposed to be, after that, the tune itself I can remember...






Thanks Bruno. I don't play fiddle or mandolin, but I do like to dabble with fiddle tabs I've found. My goal in learning basic fiddle tabs is to tab out basic melodies that I can practice backup banjo. As far as I understand H & L represent high and low notes possibly an octive apart ? I am just not sure.






 

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/10/2021:  22:59:12


Thankyou

mmuussiiccaall - Posted - 05/11/2021:  00:05:46


Good to hear from you Archie, here's a web page that explains finger positions.
violinonline.com/fingerboard-chart.html

RB-1 - Posted - 05/11/2021:  02:01:51


quote:

Originally posted by mmuussiiccaall

Good to hear from you Archie, here's a web page that explains finger positions.

violinonline.com/fingerboard-chart.html






Archie and Rick, isn't it funny, Banjo Hangouters running into each other over here again? yes



Now I can see where this 1H and 1L comes from, but to me a chromatic approach, like with  fretted instruments, feels so much more intuitive. As in no four numbers with extra indications, but one for every semi tone. enlightened



I heard an explanation that "because of the key you're playing in, all fingers have fixed positions".



Tell that to a banjo player.... devil



With almost 60 years of mandolin playing under the belt, this diatonic approach to fiddle tab makes no sense to me at all. frown



Learning the fiddle backwards, as in "I'm all over the fingerboard already, playing double stops, slides, etc.", while at the same time, the right hand has a lot of catching up to do. surprise



But getting another bow finally helped me over the hurdle of scratching less and having a half decent tone at last. laugh



But to each his own, I guess...wink



 



 

BanjoBrad - Posted - 05/11/2021:  11:27:44


That H/L notation is one of the biggest reasons I use notation for fiddle. It is much simpler (2 notes at a time max) than trying to read banjo tab, plus it gives you a head start on actually understanding notation.

Or, you could use the note-name method of notation that is available in Tabledit. That shows you the note name (A, B, C#, etc) on the string being played.

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/11/2021:  23:51:57


quote:

Originally posted by RB-1

quote:

Originally posted by mmuussiiccaall

Good to hear from you Archie, here's a web page that explains finger positions.

violinonline.com/fingerboard-chart.html






Archie and Rick, isn't it funny, Banjo Hangouters running into each other over here again? yes



There was too much infighting - legal threats when I was active on the BHO.  I got so fed up with it all and walked away leaving them to get on with it. The  time I wasted over there and the misinformation I was fed as a newbie  it was a relief to have the time to sit down and actually study banjo with a great teacher. BanjoBen 



If you dig around the Fiddle TAB Tef files here you'll find some great banjo TABs   



Edited by - Tam_Zeb on 05/12/2021 00:03:47

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/11/2021:  23:52:52


quote:

Originally posted by mmuussiiccaall

Good to hear from you Archie, here's a web page that explains finger positions.

violinonline.com/fingerboard-chart.html






Thanks Richard.

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/11/2021:  23:57:32


quote:

Originally posted by BanjoBrad

That H/L notation is one of the biggest reasons I use notation for fiddle. It is much simpler (2 notes at a time max) than trying to read banjo tab, plus it gives you a head start on actually understanding notation.



Or, you could use the note-name method of notation that is available in Tabledit. That shows you the note name (A, B, C#, etc) on the string being played.






Hi Fred 



I am a banjo player so reading banjo tab is not a problem for me, in fact I write a lot of my own TABs. Which is why I raised the query. Once I learn how to enter these symbols in TablEdit I should be able to write some basic fiddle melodies.

BanjoBrad - Posted - 05/12/2021:  14:44:41


Archie - Yeah, I know you over on BHO, I use the same handle there as here. I've read music since 3rd grade for piano and guitar, but that danged reentrant 5th string hung me up on notation, so I now read tab for guitar (and some fiddle), but prefer the notation for fiddle.

The H/L is easy once you get your head around it, though. Your choice.

Tam_Zeb - Posted - 05/13/2021:  07:11:27


quote:

Originally posted by BanjoBrad

Archie - Yeah, I know you over on BHO, I use the same handle there as here. I've read music since 3rd grade for piano and guitar, but that danged reentrant 5th string hung me up on notation, so I now read tab for guitar (and some fiddle), but prefer the notation for fiddle.



The H/L is easy once you get your head around it, though. Your choice.






Must be about six maybe seven years since I posted on the BHO Fred you must have a good memory. You can always find me on Banjo Bens forum. Much more helpful and friendy over there for banjo players.

Hide these ads: join the Players Union!

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.046875