Visit FiddleVideo.com

 All Forums
 Other Fiddle-Related Topics
 Other Fiddle-Related Topics
 Old-Time Music Double Standards

 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Print

Next Page

 

 

Page: of 2

soppinthegravy

171 posts
since 7/26/15

02/14/2017 13:24:21 View soppinthegravy's MP3 Archive View soppinthegravy's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Are there double standards in the Old-Time Music genre? 


Edited by - soppinthegravy on 02/14/2017 13:24:58

Lonesome Fiddler

1006 posts since 12/11/08

02/14/2017 14:09:49View Lonesome Fiddler's MP3 Archive View Lonesome Fiddler's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Of course.  There's Stan, and then there's Dard.

Go to Top of Page

Ron

United States
116 posts since 6/25/07

02/14/2017 14:31:28 View Ron's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

In what way?

Go to Top of Page

tonyelder

United States
5262 posts since 8/7/09

02/14/2017 14:32:25View tonyelder's MP3 Archive View tonyelder's Photo Albums View tonyelder's Blog Reply with Quote

"double standards" - is that supposed to be included in a glossary of musical terms? ...or is it intended as a commentary about the different life styles of old time musicians?

Go to Top of Page

Old Scratch

Canada
110 posts since 6/22/16

02/14/2017 17:45:53 Reply with Quote

Yes !   Well - no.  Um ... maybe ....

Go to Top of Page

alaskafiddler

2073 posts since 9/13/09

02/14/2017 17:49:12View alaskafiddler's MP3 Archive View alaskafiddler's Photo Albums View alaskafiddler's Blog Reply with Quote

There are standards like "Cluck Old Hen" - one standard is in A minor with G chord; the other standard is A major (mixolydian) with an E chord. " Many many other tunes have double standards...

Probably meant something else, though not sure what you are specifically referring to, but I would say NO - Old-time is just generic label... which involves a pretty wide diversity of interpretations. There is no official governing board or rules that define any standard.   Due to the diversity, "people" might introduce or have double standards.

Go to Top of Page

fiddlinsteudel

United States
2259 posts since 7/12/13

02/15/2017 10:37:01View fiddlinsteudel's MP3 Archive View fiddlinsteudel's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Maybe he meant, they publicly denounce any non-old-timey songs in public, but secretly play jazz music when no one else is around

Go to Top of Page

Fiddler

United States
3488 posts since 6/22/07

02/15/2017 10:56:10View Fiddler's MP3 Archive View Fiddler's Photo Albums View Fiddler's Blog Reply with Quote

...or are "double standards" those crossover hits that can be found in both OT and BG.  (BlackMtnRag, Redwing, Soldier's Joy, etc.)

Like others, not quite sure to what the question refers.

Go to Top of Page

ChickenMan

United States
3065 posts since 9/26/08

02/15/2017 12:06:55View ChickenMan's MP3 Archive View ChickenMan's Photo Albums View ChickenMan's Blog Reply with Quote

Merriam Webster says this:
double standard - a set of principles that applies differently and usually more rigorously to one group of people or circumstances than to another; especially : a code of morals that applies more severe standards of sexual behavior to women than to men.

I'm not sure if this is what soppin' was getting at (probably not the gender specific position at least).


Edited by - ChickenMan on 02/15/2017 12:07:24

Go to Top of Page

soppinthegravy

171 posts since 7/26/15

02/15/2017 13:50:44View soppinthegravy's MP3 Archive View soppinthegravy's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Yep. Something along those lines.

quote:
Originally posted by fiddlinsteudel

Maybe he meant, they publicly denounce any non-old-timey songs in public, but secretly play jazz music when no one else is around





Edited by - soppinthegravy on 02/15/2017 14:04:37

Go to Top of Page

GeeDubya

United States
746 posts since 3/10/08

02/15/2017 14:14:34View GeeDubya's MP3 Archive View GeeDubya's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Offer up some of those "public denunciations" please.  My experience with traditional musicians of all stripes is they are proponents of their cultural heritage in public but, like most serious musicians, appreciate (and sometimes play) a variety of musical styles when off-stage.

.

Go to Top of Page

gapbob

United States
345 posts since 4/20/08

02/15/2017 14:26:07 Send gapbob an AOL message Reply with Quote

I remember a fellow who said that the only old-time music there was existed 20 miles of Mt. Airy.  Seriously.  So I guess that is one standard.  Everybody else is the other.

Go to Top of Page

ChickenMan

United States
3065 posts since 9/26/08

02/15/2017 14:54:03View ChickenMan's MP3 Archive View ChickenMan's Photo Albums View ChickenMan's Blog Reply with Quote

Welcome to old time fiddlers anonymous.
Hello, my name is Billy and I play old time. (Hi Billy)
I also play at Irish and bluegrass. Bluegrassers think I sound Irish, Irish players think I sound bluegrassy, the old time players seem to think I sound just right. In each instance, I'm trying to get the accent right, but old time has thousands of hours more time spent than the other two so that's what wins.
What standards are we talking about here? Bowing? Intonation? Rhythm? I personally think those are pretty important and quantitative aspects of fiddling, and I think they're important in all those genres. Do they compare equally in each genre? That is a question of standards, eh. I'd say no with qualifications. Each genre probably has a different ordering, say rhythm, intonation, bowing or intonation, bowing, rhythm - because each genre has a history. Bluegrass, being the newest and from a slick and professional origin, probably has the highest "standard" of all three of those aspects. Old time, with its plethora of recordings of very old fiddlers, often well past their prime and thus pretty rough sounding on occasion, might have wound up setting the bar quite a bit lower based on these records and maybe the hippies [ ;-)] were just more welcoming to all comers and the waters got a little muddied as the beginners badly outnumbered the more practiced /immersed individuals. Still, you'll find the higher one's skill set is, the more universal appeal they seem to have. Whatever that's worth (possibly a paycheck). What about Irish? High standards, history of dance accompaniment, rhythm being tantamount. That information comes from endless threads at The Session dot org so take it or leave it. There are other more esoteric qualities to fiddling like Drive, Lift, Soul, Energy that are not really measurable but still seem to relate to "a standard".
Or maybe that's not what you mean either. Thanks for listening and... Give me strength to accept the tunes I can't play today and give me the time to learn them tomorrow....


Edited by - ChickenMan on 02/15/2017 14:58:51

Go to Top of Page

alaskafiddler

2073 posts since 9/13/09

02/15/2017 15:40:03View alaskafiddler's MP3 Archive View alaskafiddler's Photo Albums View alaskafiddler's Blog Reply with Quote

quote:
Originally posted by soppinthegravy

Yep. Something along those lines.
quote:
Originally posted by fiddlinsteudel
 

Maybe he meant, they publicly denounce any non-old-timey songs in public, but secretly play jazz music when no one else is around

 

 


That describes individuals... and there are individuals that have double standards. (probably in every genre).

Go to Top of Page

farmerjones

United States
1210 posts since 10/22/07

02/16/2017 08:36:26 View farmerjones's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

 The people i know that play authentic traditional music of their ancestors, don't call it "old time." They simply play what they know, and call them "tunes."  

Them that have gotten into the resurgence of contra dance, and have mostly learned the tunes from Ryan's Mammoth or Portland collection. These people call this music Old Time.

It's all good! There are so few fiddlers, i feel if you're doing it, Shine On! I'll play anything from a Hymn to Classical, to Nine Inch Nails.

 

Go to Top of Page

fiddlinsteudel

United States
2259 posts since 7/12/13

02/16/2017 09:46:58View fiddlinsteudel's MP3 Archive View fiddlinsteudel's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

quote:
Originally posted by wooliver

It's all good! There are so few fiddlers, i feel if you're doing it, Shine On! I'll play anything from a Hymn to Classical, to Nine Inch Nails.

 


Now I want to hear the Nine inch nail cover!

Go to Top of Page

farmerjones

United States
1210 posts since 10/22/07

02/16/2017 13:07:03 View farmerjones's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

quote:   
Now I want to hear the Nine inch nail cover!
 

I know you've heard Johnny Cash's version of Hurt. That's right up there with The Blackest Crow. (not a NIN tune but a real pick-me-up)

Go to Top of Page

Mojohand40

United States
842 posts since 6/13/11

02/17/2017 07:11:05View Mojohand40's MP3 Archive View Mojohand40's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

quote:
Originally posted by wooliver
 
quote:   
Now I want to hear the Nine inch nail cover!
 

I know you've heard Johnny Cash's version of Hurt. That's right up there with The Blackest Crow. (not a NIN tune but a real pick-me-up)


...off topic, but I don't think this thread has a topic, LOL

That version of Hurt is amazing, isn't it..

This guy seems to do a good job with it on fiddle:

http://youtu.be/3lg1EeJZS60

.... I don't know any NIN tunes,yet...(I may have to learn Hurt..hmmm)

But, here is a good one played on violin:

http://youtu.be/bHAdcBY1Pqc

...I have been working up "Black Hole Sun" by Soundgarden.  Actually makes a pretty good fiddle tune...also been learning a little "The Man Who Sold The World", which was a Bowie song covered and made popular by Nirvana. 

oh yeah...back on topic: Does Old Time have Double standards?  umm....yes and no.

 


Edited by - Mojohand40 on 02/17/2017 07:14:20

Go to Top of Page

Lonesome Fiddler

1006 posts since 12/11/08

02/18/2017 13:23:55View Lonesome Fiddler's MP3 Archive View Lonesome Fiddler's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

I've been asked to fiddle Guns N' Roses' November Rain at my nephew's wedding.

Go to Top of Page

groundhogpeggy

9540 posts since 9/23/09

02/21/2017 10:04:22View groundhogpeggy's MP3 Archive View groundhogpeggy's Photo Albums View groundhogpeggy's Blog Reply with Quote

Do you mean the idea of carefully preserving the tunes as passed down in one particular geographical locstion or heritage, it as passed down by some great fiddler of the past, as opposed to taking the tunes and allowing them to evolve with the times, hopefully by musicians who know how to keep the tunes running true, or as opposed to downright changing the tunes to keep up with rap artists, etc.????  If so....yes, there might be double standards.

Go to Top of Page

boxbowPlayers Union Member

United States
2078 posts since 2/3/11

02/21/2017 12:23:47 View boxbow's Photo Albums View boxbow's Blog Reply with Quote

quote:
Originally posted by groundhogpeggy
 

Do you mean the idea of carefully preserving the tunes as passed down in one particular geographical locstion or heritage, it as passed down by some great fiddler of the past, as opposed to taking the tunes and allowing them to evolve with the times, hopefully by musicians who know how to keep the tunes running true, or as opposed to downright changing the tunes to keep up with rap artists, etc.????  If so....yes, there might be double standards.


And there it is.  Does my idea of "running true" suit the next guy?  Or the next?  The phrase "double standard" implies that some undesirable characteristic is involved and that possibly nefarious ends are camouflaged by a carefully calculated normality.  Or something.

This is folk music, after all, and it must therefor pass through many hands to get...where, exactly?  If you've got an answer to that then you've figured out running true.

I'm just gonna play what suits me, which is most often what suits my picking partners or my best attempt at such.  It's hard enough to stay in tune, let alone authentic.

Go to Top of Page

groundhogpeggy

9540 posts since 9/23/09

02/21/2017 12:43:20View groundhogpeggy's MP3 Archive View groundhogpeggy's Photo Albums View groundhogpeggy's Blog Reply with Quote

I totally agree, Walter!

Go to Top of Page

carlbPlayers Union Member

United States
1951 posts since 2/2/08

02/22/2017 04:45:36View carlb's MP3 Archive View carlb's Photo Albums View carlb's Blog Reply with Quote

Whenever I teach someone the ins and outs of a tune, I almost always supply them with a audio version from which I learned it. While i may not play it exactly as that original, the person can then develop their own way from the version where I learned it, rather then from how I play it now.

Go to Top of Page

Joel Glassman

United States
145 posts since 4/22/09

02/22/2017 19:09:24 Reply with Quote

"Are there double standards in the Old-Time Music genre?"
Double standard describes a bias or unfairness.
A rule or principle that is unfairly applied in different ways to different people or groups.
I don't think so, but this reminds me of something.
I was deep into Clark Kessinger in 1975, and there was a group who played Tommy Jarrell
music exclusively in the park on saturday mornings. They were deep into the folkloric nuance
of Round Peak music and I wasn't. Not generally a good match for them. :^)
It was a bias I guess, but not unfair. A little frustrating, but a good lesson for me on
how to find a place in the music [which was more rhythmic in this case.]
Eventually some other oldtime musicians showed up that summer who were in the
Chicken Chokers and weren't so doctrinaire. Much more fun to jam with.

Go to Top of Page

soppinthegravy

171 posts since 7/26/15

02/23/2017 15:07:53View soppinthegravy's MP3 Archive View soppinthegravy's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Double standard wasn't the right word. I guess what I'm wondering is if anybody thinks there is hypocrisy on the part of a lot of mainstream Old-Time players. In my opinion, there is, because they claim to stick to Southern Appalachian traditions, but the majority of the dances they hold are contras, which are not traditional for southern Appalachia, and although they claim to eliminate Bluegrass influence for the sake of avoiding sounding modern, they incorporate elements from other styles of music that are newer than Bluegrass. Also, they claim to honor the old folks, but they rarely show respect to living senior musicians.   


Edited by - soppinthegravy on 02/23/2017 15:10:08

Go to Top of Page

tonyelder

United States
5262 posts since 8/7/09

02/23/2017 20:08:25View tonyelder's MP3 Archive View tonyelder's Photo Albums View tonyelder's Blog Reply with Quote

I think it is entirely possible for anyone of us to be judged or called a hypocrite - for any number of different reasons. And I think it just as likely that the one doing the judging or calling could - most likely - be judged or called one too.

"Oh my honey can't you see, ya wanna go to heaven, you gotta be like me".


Edited by - tonyelder on 02/23/2017 20:14:27

Go to Top of Page

 

 

Page: of 2
Next Page

 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Print

Jump To:

Want to hide these Google ads? Join the Players Union!




You are not logged in.
Log In


Not a member? Create an Account (FREE!)



919 FIDDLE LOVERS ONLINE

HOME | FORUMS | MEMBERS | MEDIA ARCHIVE | TABS & LESSONS | CLASSIFIEDS | REVIEWS | LINKS | CALENDAR | STORE | TERMS OF USE
Viewing desktop version - switch to mobile version